Valenzuela burmeisteri
Apparently a common species.
I really struggled to identify this. Using the Barkfly Recording Scheme key I did land on the right ID as the most likely ID but it wasn't convincing, as it indicates this species should have a pale line alongside the pterostigma and radial vein. Looking at a variety of magnifications, different lighting and different angles I simply could not make out any hint of this pale line. So with no clear answer from the website I turned to the RES key by T R New. The key here demanded views of two bits of anatomy that I am not familiar with - the distal inner labral sensilla and the lacinia. Unable to see these on the dried specimen I resorted to clearing the head in potassium hydroxide solution, but still couldn't make out either, even under the compound microscope. I left it clearing further in euparal essence for 2-3 days and went back to it. Eventually, I think I worked out where the inner labral sensilla were, but I still couldn't convincingly match up any of the diagrams with what I could see - I think they are just a bit too awkward to see against the outer labral lip. I had a bit more luck this time finding the lacinia, looking at the mouthparts from underneath. This had rounded lobes and even without the labral sensilla that seems to be enough to continue to the next steps in the key. Notably, this key does not require the presence of a pale line alongside the pterostigma and radial vein on burmeisteri, so that now feels like a satisfactory conclusion.
Valenzuela burmeisteri showing wings, lacinia and two views of the labral groove, North Elmham (Norfolk, UK), 22nd May 2020
Having struggled with the last one I was keen to examine another, so was pleased when sorting through my unidentified barkfly specimens to find what initially looked like this species. However, I was sorting the specimens to genus really, in order to go through each group more thoroughly, so did not at this stage carefully and critically rule out other Valenzuela species. Much to my dismay, when I later returned to the specimen pot in order to confirm the species, I found the pot empty! Not sure what happened there, but there's probably a barkfly specimen somewhere in my study that I may or may not ever find again. Anyway, now the question is, can I without being able to examine the specimen any further, be sure that this is indeed burmeisteri? I think it is possible to rule out other Valenzuela species from these two photos, so although it feels rather unsatisfactory, I am provisionally putting it down as burmeisteri. I'm happy to take advice if anyone thinks this isn't safe.
Valenzuela burmeisteri, North Elmham (Norfolk, UK), 14th July 2023
I don't know why I attempted to identify this one at the time, while holding back the earlier ones to identify later, but anyway, the absence of a pale line alongside the pterostigma and radial vein was probably the reason I did not identify it as Valenzuela burmeisteri. Using the Barkfly Recording Scheme key the only option that seemed to fit was Elipsocus sp., and that's what I called it. However now armed with much more experience of Elipsocus, I think this must have been wrong - it really doesn't look like Elipsocus, either the overall appearance of the insect (too yellow) or the wing pattern (e.g. smaller areola postica). So I wonder if this was also Valenzuela burmeisteri? Or am I missing something else?
possible Valenzuela burmeisteri, North Elmham (Norfolk, UK), 23rd July 2020
Likewise I struggled to identify this one using the Barkfly Recording Scheme key, and ended up calling it Elipsocus sp. But like the last one, that surely cannot be correct and the only thing I can see that might be is Valenzuela burmeisteri. But I'm not convinced - why do none of these show the pale line alongside the pterostigma and radial vein? What am I missing? It's worth noting that what look like pale spots in the forewing in the first photo may not be real - it was in a pot and the photo taken through glass so these may just be spots on the glass in front of the wing.
possible Valenzuela burmeisteri, Wendling Beck Project (Norfolk, UK), 23rd July 2024
After finishing examining my remaining barkfly specimens I realised I had one outstanding barkfly from Cumbria that I'd not looked at yet. Having agonised over the ones above I was pleased to find that it was another, so another chance to see if I could make out the finer details. Once again I couldn't make out the pale line alongside the pterostigma and radial vein, but as I was taking photos of this, I realised that in my photos I could, just, make out the subtlest of pale lines, at least below the pterostigma. I had to look really hard to convince myself that it wasn't my imagination but I think it really is there! But this hard to see, and I can't see it on all my photos of the same wing, so I think I could have easily overlooked it previously.
Still slightly worried that I was getting these wrong, potentially even in the wrong genus, I tried to key it fully using New. It keyed to the family ok but I struggled to get further as I find it virtually impossible to see the detail of the labral sensilla even at high magnification. I couldn't work out exactly what angle I should be viewing it from, but from any angle the best I can say is that it had some similarity to New's 'type-2' form (which is correct for Valenzuela). It wasn't in all honesty a firm confirmation that it was 'type-2', but at least it looks plausible. The lacinial apex was clear enough to be able to firmly eliminate Enderleinella in the key to genera, and looked best for Valenzuela atricornis/burmeisteri/flavidus although I'm not 100% sure I would have been able to make the tiny denticles if it had had them. Working through the Valenzuela key, burmeisteri seemed to be the best fit (and here there is no mention of the pale line in the wing). The diagram of the lacinial apex is closest to what I think I can see but I'm struggling to make out the detail on the epiproct. I think it probably matches burmeisteri best, but I'm not clear enough about that to say this confirms it.
Despite the challenges, I think the balance of evidence is sufficiently heavily in favour of burmeisteri to leave me feeling content that it is correctly identified as such.
male Valenzuela burmeisteri showing left wings, right wings, close-up of area below pterostigma (2 views), lacinial apex (before and after clearing), labrum (3 angles), epiproct (from both sides) and phallasome, Thornthwaite (Cumbria, UK), 8th July 2023